0
Case Stories
❌ EB-3 to EB-2 Transfer - I-485 Denied Due to I-140 Gap - India PD 2013-12
E
· 12 views
❌ **Case Status: Denied**
---
Applicant with EB-2 I-140 approved in 2013 filed concurrent EB-3 I-140 and I-485 in 2020, but EB-3 I-140 was denied due to job title mismatch. After filing I-485J to port to EB-2, the I-485 was denied in February 2026 due to a ~6-month gap between the EB-3 denial and EB-2 becoming current. Applicant now holds an approved EB-1A I-140 with current priority date and is evaluating whether to refile I-485 before or after H-1B renewal.
This case involves a complex multi-year green card journey beginning with an EB-2 I-140 approval in December 2013. When EB-3 priority dates became favorable in October 2020, the applicant filed a concurrent EB-3 I-140 and I-485. The EB-3 I-140 was subsequently denied due to a job title discrepancy between attorney and HR documentation. An I-485J (job portability supplement) was filed to transfer the pending I-485 to the original EB-2 I-140 basis.
The I-485 was denied in February 2026. USCIS cited a gap in continuous I-140 coverage: the EB-3 I-140 denial came in October 2021, and subsequent MTR and AAO appeal dismissals concluded in April 2021 (with EB-2 not becoming current until the same month), creating approximately a 6-month window with no valid underlying I-140 to support the I-485 portability claim.
A completed I-485 interview occurred in June 2023, after which the case entered 'Case Ready for Interview' (CRP) status for nearly three years before denial. The applicant was granted a new EB-1A I-140 approval in August 2025 with a current priority date. Current status: H-1B valid through September 2026, last U.S. entry on Advance Parole in November 2024 (now revoked upon I-485 denial), and I-94 reflecting parolee status. No valid AP or EAD currently exists.
The applicant faces a strategic decision: refile I-485 immediately (locking in 180-day AC21 portability clock before H-1B amendment) versus amending/extending H-1B first to establish a clean I-94 status before refiling I-485.
---
**[📎 View Original Post](https://www.reddit.com/r/USCIS/comments/1ri5jia/unique_situation_need_guidance/)**
*Source: Reddit EB-3 search*
---
*This post was automatically curated from online sources to share real case experiences with the community.*
This case highlights a critical but underappreciated risk in I-485 portability: USCIS requires an unbroken chain of approved I-140s at the time of porting — any gap, even if brief and caused by appeals, can be fatal to the I-485. The 6-month gap here between the EB-3 denial chain concluding and EB-2 becoming current illustrates how MTR/AAO timelines can inadvertently create coverage gaps. For applicants in similar situations with multiple I-140s across categories, it is essential to map out the exact dates of all I-140 approvals, denials, and appeals, and confirm that EB-2 or EB-1 priority dates were current during any gap period. Additionally, those who last entered on AP and whose I-485 is subsequently denied face an I-94 parolee status issue that complicates H-1B reinstatement — consulting an attorney about the sequence of H-1B COS versus fresh I-485 filing is critical, as the order of filings can affect underlying status claims.