❌ EB-3 F1 AOS Denied - USCIS Identity Mismatch Error - USC Spouse PD Recent

❌ **Case Status: Denied** --- An F-1 student who married a U.S. citizen had their I-485 denied without any NOID or RFE. The denial reason cited a prior I-485 filing in 2005 and green card issuance in 2006, which is impossible as the applicant was 4 years old in 2005 and first entered the U.S. in 2019. This appears to be a USCIS database error involving identity confusion with another individual. F-1 visa holder married to a U.S. citizen filed an I-485 adjustment of status application. The I-130 was approved. The applicant completed school and is currently on valid F-1 OPT status. The I-485 was denied without any prior NOID or RFE. The denial notice stated USCIS believed the applicant had previously filed an I-485 in 2005 and received a green card in 2006, instructing them to file an I-90 instead. The applicant was approximately 4 years old in 2005 and did not enter the United States until 2019 on an F-1 student visa. This strongly suggests a USCIS administrative error — likely a biographic data match error or a file merge error where records from another individual were incorrectly associated with this applicant's A-number or biographic profile. --- **[📎 View Original Post](https://www.reddit.com/r/USCIS/comments/1uk260d/denied_without_any_noid_or_rfe/)** *Source: Reddit I-485 EB* --- *This post was automatically curated from online sources to share real case experiences with the community.*